Reviewer Comments Reviewer 1 - Minor Essential

Interactive comment on “Seasonal predictability of the winter precipitation over Iberian Peninsula and its relationship with finite-time Lyapunov exponents” by Daniel Garaboa-Paz et al

We would like to thank the Referee for his/her valuable comments and critics that we tried to take into account in the revised version of the manuscript. Hopefully, all the major and minor corrections pointed out by the reviewer have been corrected now. A detailed answer follows below. We provide replies to the reviewer’ comments in bold. As well, corrections included in the manuscript are mark...

Detailed Response to Reviewer Comments Reviewer :

Review History of 2009ja015069

Below and/or attached are two reviews of the above manuscript. I am pleased to report that Reviewer #1 finds the manuscript acceptable for publication but Reviewer #2 still has some strong concerns. I have some sympathy with the view expressed in your covering letter, that Reviewer #2 may have a biased attitude. However, it would be inappropriate for me to entirely ignore their comments, so I p...

Interactive comment on “Impact of Optimal Observational Time Window on Coupled Data Assimilation: Simulation with a Simple Climate Model” by Yuxin Zhao et al

Reviewer 1# A few tel-conferences of all co-authors have been held to discuss the comments from reviewer #1. All authors converge to the point that all the comments are very important and useful for authors to improve the quality of this manuscript (MS). Therefore, all comments from reviewer #1 have been fully addressed in the revision. Now we will reply to each comment point by point as follow...

Author’s response to reviews Title: ASSOCIATION BETWEEN CARDIORESPIRATORY FITNESS AND METABOLIC RISK FACTORS IN A POPULATION WITH MILD TO SEVERE OBESITY Authors:

Title: ASSOCIATION BETWEEN CARDIORESPIRATORY FITNESS AND METABOLIC RISK FACTORS IN A POPULATION WITH MILD TO SEVERE OBESITY Authors: Kathy Do ([email protected]) Ruth Brown ([email protected]) Sean Wharton ([email protected]) Chris Ardern ([email protected]) Jennifer Kuk ([email protected]) Version: 1 Date: 02 Jan 2018 Author’s response to reviews: Reviewer reports: C.J. Lavie (Re...